Titleist Players S4 StaDry Stand Bag vs Titleist Players S5 Stand Bag

The Quick Verdict

Get the S5. It's $30 less at list, has a 5-way top versus the S4's 4-way, and carries two more pockets — and both bags weigh 5 lbs. The S4 StaDry makes sense if waterproof construction is a priority for you: seam-sealed zippers and a waterproof valuables pocket are real features, not marketing fluff. But if you're not buying this bag specifically to play in the rain, the S5 gives you more organization for less money.

What They Have in Common

Both are 5 lb stand bags with full-length dividers, a premium double strap, cart strap tunnel, stand legs, and YKK zippers. Same brand. Titleist doesn't publish a top size, material, or rain hood for either one, so those can't factor into the comparison.

Where They Differ

Top and club organization

The S4 has a 4-way top; the S5 has a 5-way. Both have full-length dividers, which means each slot runs the full length of the bag — no club tangling at the bottom, and you'll notice immediately when you've left a club on the green. The extra slot on the S5 isn't dramatic, but a 5-way gives you a bit more breathing room to keep your short irons separate from your mid-irons without doubling up. A 4-way top is workable for most sets, but you're fitting more clubs per slot.

Pockets and storage

The S5 carries 10 pockets; the S4 has 8. Two pockets might not sound meaningful, but that's the difference between "I'll just toss it somewhere" and actually having a dedicated spot for your rangefinder, your snacks, and your phone without digging. Both bags have a magnetic tee pocket and a velcro glove landing patch on the S5. The S4 has a waterproof valuables pocket — specifically called out — which the S5 doesn't list.

Waterproof construction

This is the real fork between these two bags. The S4 StaDry has Titleist's seam-sealed waterproof construction throughout, including the zippers. The S5 makes no waterproof claim. If you play somewhere that gets afternoon rain regularly, or you don't want to think about whether to grab a cover, the S4 is the bag for that. If you play mostly in good weather or just keep a rain cover in the car, you're paying $30 more for protection you may never use.

Price

The S5 lists at $310. The S4 lists at $340. Thirty dollars at list isn't a huge gap, but when both bags weigh the same and the S5 offers more organization, the S4 needs waterproofing to justify the premium — and it does, if that matters to you.

Who Should Buy Which

Get the Titleist Players S5 Stand Bag if:

• You want the more organized bag of the two — 10 pockets and a 5-way top at $310 list is the better default setup for most walking rounds.
• Weather isn't a regular concern and you'd rather put the $30 toward something else.
• You like having a velcro glove patch, which the S5 lists and the S4 doesn't.

Get the Titleist Players S4 StaDry Stand Bag if:

• You play in a climate where rain is a real part of your golf calendar — the seam-sealed zippers and waterproof valuables pocket mean you're not reaching into a wet pocket mid-round.
• You want a stand bag sold as waterproof rather than relying on a separate rain cover.
• You're willing to give up two pockets and a divider slot for the waterproof construction.

The Bottom Line

These are nearly the same bag with two differences: the S4 is waterproof and the S5 has more storage for less money. At the same weight, same strap setup, same stand system, and same brand, the S4's $30 premium is paying for weatherproofing and nothing else. That's a fair trade if you need it. If you don't, the S5 is the better value — more pockets, one more divider slot, and $30 back in your wallet.

Get the Titleist Players S5 Stand Bag.