Get the Garmin Approach S44.
Par and Peg may earn a commission when you buy through links on this page. More info.
| Blue Tees Player Pro | Garmin Approach S44 | |
|---|---|---|
| Price (MSRP) | $199.98Lower price | $299.99 |
Get the Garmin Approach S44.
Get the Garmin Approach S44. It costs $100 more, but it's a proper GPS watch that you wear — hands-free, always there, genuinely useful between shots. The Blue Tees Player Pro is a Bluetooth speaker that also does GPS, and it does that GPS job well, but it's a cart device. Get the Player Pro if your foursome actually wants cart audio and you're happy leaving the GPS plugged into the cart all round.
Both run GPS-based yardages from a similar course library (42,000 vs 43,000+), both have full-color touchscreens, both offer green views and hazard distances, both charge via USB-C, and neither requires a subscription for basic front/center/back distances. That's roughly where the similarities end.
This comparison is a bit unusual because these two devices aren't really competing for the same job. The Player Pro is a golf cart speaker with a GPS screen built in. The Approach S44 is a golf watch. One lives on your cart; the other lives on your wrist.
That matters more than it sounds. On a walking round, the Player Pro is a 30W speaker you're carrying like a bag. On a cart round, it magnets to the cart frame and doubles as both audio system and GPS — which is genuinely useful if you were planning to bring a speaker anyway. The S44 goes on your wrist at the first tee and stays there all day. You glance at it mid-fairway without breaking stride, without touching your phone, without fishing anything out of a bag.
The S44 runs a 1.2-inch AMOLED display. AMOLED in sunlight is typically very good — bright, high-contrast, readable at a glance. The Player Pro has a full-color touchscreen too, but Blue Tees doesn't publish screen size or resolution. Given it's a speaker unit (not a watch), the screen is almost certainly larger in raw inches, which helps when it's mounted on a cart and you're reading from a few feet away.
Neither has automatic shot detection. The S44 does manual shot tracking on the watch and is compatible with Garmin CT1/CT10 club sensors (sold separately, roughly $30–50 per sensor or $200+ for a full CT10 set). If you want actual shot history and distance-by-club data, the sensor route gets expensive but gives you clean data per club. The Player Pro tracks shot distance — distance only, marked manually — without any sensor add-on. That's fine for basic "how far did I hit that" purposes, nothing more.
This is the Player Pro's most important caveat. Blue Tees includes 6 months of their GAME AI Intelligence Package at purchase, but that package contains features you'd expect to be standard: green heat maps (slope and break), True Distance (slope adjustments), and the Dynamic Hole View screen. After 6 months, those features lock behind $79/yr. If you're comparing on green contour access — that's effectively a subscription feature on the Pro.
The S44 also has a paid tier: Garmin Golf membership at $99.99/yr unlocks green contours, PlaysLike Distance, and enhanced maps. Neither watch gives you free green contours long-term, but the S44's free tier is more clearly delineated from the start. Three-year cost of ownership: Player Pro at $199.98 + $79/yr (after 6 months) is roughly $357 all-in. S44 at $299.99 + $99.99/yr if you want contours is ~$500. If neither of you cares about contours or slope features, skip the subscriptions on both.
The S44 is rated 15 hours in GPS mode and 10 days in watch mode. Blue Tees gives no official GPS hours for the Player Pro — Amazon says "10+ hours," PGA TOUR Superstore says "up to 14 hours," and Blue Tees' own blog says "two full rounds with GPS active and music playing at moderate volume." Call it 10–14 hours depending on volume and conditions. Probably enough for most rounds, but the S44's 15-hour figure is at least a published number.
Both have slope and wind adjustment. On the S44, slope is straightforward on-device. On the Player Pro, True Distance (slope and wind adjustment) is part of the AI package — works great during the 6-month trial, then it's $79/yr.
Get the Blue Tees Player Pro if:
Get the Garmin Approach S44 if:
The Approach S44 is the better GPS device in most situations. It's hands-free, it's wrist-worn, it has a sharp AMOLED display, 15 hours of GPS battery, and tournament mode. The $100 price gap is real, but you're getting a fundamentally more versatile tool — not a cart-mounted speaker with GPS tacked on.
The Player Pro isn't a bad product. If you wanted a cart speaker anyway, adding GPS for free is a smart design. But if GPS is the primary need, build your setup around the right device for that job.
Get the Garmin Approach S44.