Get the Garmin Approach S44.
Par and Peg may earn a commission when you buy through links on this page. More info.
| Garmin Approach S44 | Shot Scope G6 | |
|---|---|---|
| Price (MSRP) | $299.99 | $179.99Winner |
Get the Garmin Approach S44.
The S44 is the better watch if you want a sharp, touchscreen display and don't mind paying $300 for the hardware (plus up to $100/yr if you want the full feature set). The G6 is for golfers who want clean, readable yardages without any subscription math, at roughly half the price. Both weigh 42g and have full hole maps — that's where the similarities end. If display quality matters to you, the S44 wins easily. If you want simple and cheap, the G6 is hard to argue with.
Both are 42g golf watches with full-color hole maps on 36,000+ courses (S44 covers 43,000). Both include hazard distances, digital scoring, tournament modes, and silicone bands. Neither includes shot tracking in the base package, and neither has heart rate monitoring, sleep tracking, or music.
This is the biggest gap between these two watches. The S44 runs a 1.2-inch AMOLED touchscreen at 390 × 390 resolution behind Corning Gorilla Glass 3. The G6 runs a MIP (memory-in-pixel) display at 176 × 176 resolution behind hardened mineral glass, with button navigation only.
Those numbers mean something in practice. AMOLED screens are vivid and detailed — hole maps pop, yardages are crisp, and the touchscreen interface feels modern. MIP displays, though, are the gold standard for sunlight readability. Walk a sunny midsummer round and a MIP screen is effortless to glance at; AMOLED can wash out in harsh direct light depending on brightness settings. The G6's lower resolution is also noticeable — at 176 × 176, this is a big-number display rather than a detailed map viewer.
Neither is strictly better. It depends whether you're optimizing for visual quality or outdoor readability.
Both watches give you basic front/center/back distances, hole maps, and hazard yardages at no ongoing cost. But they diverge sharply once you want anything beyond that.
The S44's best features — PlaysLike Distance (plays-like yardage accounting for elevation) and green contours — are locked behind Garmin Golf membership at $9.99/month or $99.99/year. Green view and hazard distances are free; the smarter yardage calculations are not.
The G6 has no PlaysLike Distance and no green contours, free or otherwise. What you see is what you get, forever, with no subscription. That simplicity has real value if you don't want to think about it.
Over three years: S44 hardware ($300) + Garmin Golf membership ($300 over 3 years at $99.99/yr) = ~$600 if you want the full feature set. G6 at sale pricing ($150) + $0 in subscriptions = $150 total. That's a meaningful gap.
Neither watch comes with built-in automatic shot tracking, but the S44 at least opens the door. It's compatible with Garmin's CT1 and CT10 club sensors (sold separately), which let you track shots per club and build stats over time through the Garmin Golf app. If shot data matters to you, the S44 can get you there with additional hardware investment.
The G6 has no shot tracking capability at all — no sensor compatibility, no manual shot logging beyond the scorecard. It's a GPS distance tool, full stop.
The S44 claims 15 hours in GPS mode and 10 days in watch mode, charging via USB-C. The G6's GPS battery is listed as "2+ rounds," which is vague — probably 8–10 hours, maybe more, but Shot Scope doesn't publish a specific number. Watch mode battery is 4 days, noticeably shorter than the S44. The G6's charging method isn't specified on the product page, which is mildly annoying — probably a proprietary clip.
The S44 also wins on software features: smart notifications, slope mode, and a 2-year longer warranty baseline... wait, flip that — the G6 actually carries a 2-year warranty vs. the S44's 1-year. That's worth noting.
Get the S44 if:
Get the G6 if:
The S44 is genuinely the better GPS watch — sharper display, more feature headroom, smart notifications, USB-C charging, and a larger course database. But "better" comes with a $150 hardware premium and up to $100/yr to unlock its best tricks. The G6 costs $150 at current sale pricing, locks in everything it offers for free, and does the one job most golfers actually need: clear yardages, hole maps, and hazard distances.
If you're a golfer who wants a capable, modern watch and will use the Garmin app consistently, the S44 is worth the extra spend. If you want a functional, no-fuss GPS watch and nothing more, the G6 won't let you down.
Get the Garmin Approach S44.